Manchester United, once the gold standard of English football, continues to stumble both on and off the pitch. While the club struggles to rediscover its identity, a worrying pattern has emerged: players either stagnate at Old Trafford or leave to rediscover their form elsewhere. The recent departures and moves of key figures have left fans asking—does United itself have a deeper issue?
The most headline-grabbing case is the £40 million (approximately KSh 7.2 billion) transfer of Alejandro Garnacho to Chelsea. At just 21, the Argentine winger was widely regarded as United’s brightest young star. His decision to swap Old Trafford for Stamford Bridge suggests not only a search for a bigger role but also disillusionment with United’s current project. Losing such talent so early in his career is a bitter pill for fans to swallow.
Then there’s Marcus Rashford, once hailed as the homegrown hero destined to lead United into a new era. After years of inconsistency and criticism, Rashford has taken a bold step by joining Barcelona on loan, hoping to redeem himself away from the intense pressure of Manchester. His move reflects not just personal struggles but also the failure of the club to create an environment where local talents can flourish consistently.
Antony, too, embodies the broader problem. Signed for a staggering fee, the Brazilian has failed to establish himself as the game-changer he was expected to be. Many wonder if, like Memphis Depay or Ángel Di María before him, Antony might only shine once he leaves Old Trafford for a club with a clearer tactical system.
The pattern extends further back. Romelu Lukaku, once written off at United, became a Serie A champion with Inter Milan. Memphis Depay, mocked during his time in England, reinvented himself in France. Di María, criticized during his brief stay, returned to PSG and later won the World Cup with Argentina. The list goes on, painting a worrying picture
The consistent theme is this: Manchester United no longer seems to provide the structure, stability, and tactical clarity that top talents need to thrive. Instead, players either underperform or look elsewhere for redemption. Unless the club fixes its recruitment strategy, managerial instability, and muddled footballing vision, more Garnachos and Rashfords may slip away.
For fans, the nightmare is not just losing matches, it’s losing the players who could have been the backbone of United’s revival.